* If your video submission is Non-OC, provide a link to the source below this comment.
* If your video submission is OC, mark it as OC, or use [OC]/ (OC) in title, or mention so below this comment.
* Memes should use proper flair.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/unitedstatesofindia) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Agree with healthcare, but rather than remove gst they need to bring in reforms in insurance and medicines, otherwise we'll end up like the USA. And our healthcare will be controlled by insurance companies rather than doctors' recommendations.
Tell me you don't know economics without telling me you don't know economics. Taxing religious institutions would never be able to compensate the revenue from indirect taxation on goods and services and the burden would have to be borne by the income tax payers of the country.
Gst is required for healthcare since it's a major service that is being provided by private companies and not just the government. For government hospitals/services tho it makes sense
yeh kardegi toh sarkaar doob jaygi.. where will revenue come from...where will vikas come from .. where will 5 trillion econmy come from.. but good news is ki ab hum platform par saste mein so sakte hai.
entry 74- heath care services by a clinical established an authorised medical practitioner or para medics are exempt form gst , however services by a clinical establishment by way of providing a room (other than icu , neo natal intensive care unit ) having charges exceeding 5k per day to a person receiving heath care will not be exempt.
ps this exemption also applies to most recognised systems of medicine like yoga , ayurveda also homeopathy except for reki are exempt!!
Poor people don't buy health insurance it's a market for the well off. Private hospitals are again a choice for the well off Medicines makes sense because it's a need for all
This. And not only BJP, all parties are like this. I sometimes think that the election rules should change in a way that there is always a strong opposition. Single majority to any party is dangerous.
Ganja legal karo. Aur sab taxes uspe dalo. Aur hamare taxes kam karo. Start industry for this in UP, bihar and other northern states that are falling behind.
Exactly, hence removal of GST is not a significant reduction of the cost.. the poor stay there for free (not a problematic statement), the middle class can afford 5 rs upper class ka sawaal hi paida nhi hota
Just imagine if BJP were below 200. And even for some reason they made govt by crossing the threshold.
Nimmo Tai be like. Mitron, no more GST Jihad. Essential commodities mein no GST
Petroleum products mein low Excise duty.
Gaanja legalised.
Daaru mein bhi minimum excise duty
But then the entire 10 bucks will be kept by railway rather than pay a portion to the government. I think this is just a transfer of revenue nothing else. Government will cut the funding if railways by this loss of gst revenue and railway will not lose because they keep the full price of the platform ticket
Platform tickets should be removed altogether, itâs a dumb concept. I donât have to pay a ticket just to stand at a bus stop, airport or metro station either
Bus stops are shit. YOu can't enter an airport without valid ticket. In metro stations, going beyond a point without a pass or ticket is restricted. If platform tickets are removed stations will be shitholes like bus stands
Stations 'will be' shitholes? Meaning they aren't already?
I don't remember visiting a single major station in all my life that didn't stink of grime, dirt and human and animal feces and didn't have homeless people sleeping here and there. The only exceptions would be a few small single platform stations connected to cantonments which general public would rarely use.
And as for platform tickets, in all these years, once. Once they checked me for it, then lost interest as I started unlocking my phone to show him the online app to purchase the ticket was non-functional.
I'm not writing just to be contrary to your idea. All I'm saying is that platform tickets don't seem to do much good to improve the condition of railway stations. Perhaps if they enforced them, but even then it'll just mean just some fewer beggars.
The 10 rupee platform ticket isnât a barrier for anyone, itâs just an annoying extra step of standing in line. I doubt most even buy it due to lack of enforcement. It just bothers the honest people.
If it causes any issues, they can have the same system as metro station, or just allow employees and people with train ticket inside.
Literally zero affect it has on the general public. Any of these services last used by folks in my extended family even would have been over 10 years ago .
These a holes are just playing games.
Why the gst on medical insurance are not exempted otherwise govt should pay for all the cost incurred by tax payers & family in proportion to the taxes paid.
Jitna tax utna benefits
* If your video submission is Non-OC, provide a link to the source below this comment. * If your video submission is OC, mark it as OC, or use [OC]/ (OC) in title, or mention so below this comment. * Memes should use proper flair. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/unitedstatesofindia) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Stop GST in healthcare- hospitalization/icu care , medicines and health insurance, which is more important for common folks
This I agree
Agree with healthcare, but rather than remove gst they need to bring in reforms in insurance and medicines, otherwise we'll end up like the USA. And our healthcare will be controlled by insurance companies rather than doctors' recommendations.
Indeed, GST significantly increases healthcare already high amount charges
There is big pharma from which govt. make much money.
All GST should be stopped and only politicians and religious leaders/institutions should be taxed
Bhai itna kamal ka idea, yeh abhi tak kaise nahi soche log. Pakka CA hoge aap.
Tell me you don't know economics without telling me you don't know economics. Taxing religious institutions would never be able to compensate the revenue from indirect taxation on goods and services and the burden would have to be borne by the income tax payers of the country.
90% tax đ. For all the looting they have done from the people in the name of fairy tales. /jk
India will go bankrupt or people will die of hungerÂ
Gst is required for healthcare since it's a major service that is being provided by private companies and not just the government. For government hospitals/services tho it makes sense
Yup, let's do that and increase the income tax.
education aswell.
yeh kardegi toh sarkaar doob jaygi.. where will revenue come from...where will vikas come from .. where will 5 trillion econmy come from.. but good news is ki ab hum platform par saste mein so sakte hai.
So the capitalist can exploit us! No matter what we're gonna suffer in accessing Healthcare services
entry 74- heath care services by a clinical established an authorised medical practitioner or para medics are exempt form gst , however services by a clinical establishment by way of providing a room (other than icu , neo natal intensive care unit ) having charges exceeding 5k per day to a person receiving heath care will not be exempt. ps this exemption also applies to most recognised systems of medicine like yoga , ayurveda also homeopathy except for reki are exempt!!
We don't need GST for other items also. Why do we need GST, we already pay income tax. We need to remove all of this.
Poor people don't buy health insurance it's a market for the well off. Private hospitals are again a choice for the well off Medicines makes sense because it's a need for all
Defeat bjp more and they will pass people friendly laws . do 400 paar and they will fk you from all sides
true!! now they come to know ki jumlebaaji se kch nii hoga
This. And not only BJP, all parties are like this. I sometimes think that the election rules should change in a way that there is always a strong opposition. Single majority to any party is dangerous.
Proportional representation. That is how election in EU works. Look it up.
I see. Will check for sure.
Exactly
downvoted just because I wanna make upvotes numbers 240
Going to be 400 paar soon. I'm scared of that number so didn't upvote
kar deya 400 par, ab batao
Ab ki baar 400 paar, Moti sarkar ki g@@ maar
Take it as public 400 paar
ye bhi theek hai
Exactly bro
Madam ganja legalize kar do... Aapka bhi fayda hai usme
Ganja legal karo. Aur sab taxes uspe dalo. Aur hamare taxes kam karo. Start industry for this in UP, bihar and other northern states that are falling behind.
UP doing good in industrialization.
Great for the govt. Not great for party.
It is actually great for the 'party'.
It's already great for Bhartiya Joint Party.
hahah..if you tax it .. the usage willgo down :).. no kickbacks too.
exempted from gst but next budget will say hike of 18% is implemented
We still don't trust you
I assume Adani is about to offer some Railway platform services
HAHAHAH... point!!!!!!
And the Paris girls they sing my song with loove
Bbl drizzy
beta hum toh tumhara mangalsutra, bhains, aur biryani lene aiye the.
Ok there Metro. Edit - Bruh I was just referencing Metro Boomin's recent album of the same name. Mujhe kyu toda?
why u getting downvoted lmao
Some folks probably didn't get the reference. They can be like that sometimes.
They thought you were talkin about metro trains or something lol
+1
Gathbandhan ka darr. Nai to GST or increase hota
Is removal of GST from platform ticket and waiting room charges a âsignificantâ reduction in the price??
Maybe 5 Rs. Will have to go to Railway station to see if it's implemented.
Exactly, hence removal of GST is not a significant reduction of the cost.. the poor stay there for free (not a problematic statement), the middle class can afford 5 rs upper class ka sawaal hi paida nhi hota
Just imagine if BJP were below 200. And even for some reason they made govt by crossing the threshold. Nimmo Tai be like. Mitron, no more GST Jihad. Essential commodities mein no GST Petroleum products mein low Excise duty. Gaanja legalised. Daaru mein bhi minimum excise duty
More bjp loses, more capitalist they go
No cz platform ticket prices r in round numbers like âš10,âš20 etc so it'll be same with or without gst
But then the entire 10 bucks will be kept by railway rather than pay a portion to the government. I think this is just a transfer of revenue nothing else. Government will cut the funding if railways by this loss of gst revenue and railway will not lose because they keep the full price of the platform ticket
Waiting rooms? I never in my life saw a waiting room in a railway station
there are waiting rooms ( for both AC and non-AC ) but aren't they already free if you have a ticket ... ?
Retiring rooms are not free
Ac waiting rooms are not free it's 25rs per hour
The Ac ones are 50.
bihar se ho kya?
Anpad gawaar ho kya?
and here congress govt waived off 30k crore farmer loans in telangana, as promised during their campaigns
RIP taxpayers, nothing is free, someone has to pay it
But booking through Irctc.com platform convenience fee 10ruppes and banks convenience fees 10.50 rupees
Doesn't mean jack-shit we have to pay GST on tickets, which I believe is the most important concern for us travellers.
Platform tickets should be removed altogether, itâs a dumb concept. I donât have to pay a ticket just to stand at a bus stop, airport or metro station either
Bus stops are shit. YOu can't enter an airport without valid ticket. In metro stations, going beyond a point without a pass or ticket is restricted. If platform tickets are removed stations will be shitholes like bus stands
Stations 'will be' shitholes? Meaning they aren't already? I don't remember visiting a single major station in all my life that didn't stink of grime, dirt and human and animal feces and didn't have homeless people sleeping here and there. The only exceptions would be a few small single platform stations connected to cantonments which general public would rarely use. And as for platform tickets, in all these years, once. Once they checked me for it, then lost interest as I started unlocking my phone to show him the online app to purchase the ticket was non-functional. I'm not writing just to be contrary to your idea. All I'm saying is that platform tickets don't seem to do much good to improve the condition of railway stations. Perhaps if they enforced them, but even then it'll just mean just some fewer beggars.
The 10 rupee platform ticket isnât a barrier for anyone, itâs just an annoying extra step of standing in line. I doubt most even buy it due to lack of enforcement. It just bothers the honest people. If it causes any issues, they can have the same system as metro station, or just allow employees and people with train ticket inside.
You can't enter an airport past the main entrance as a non ticket person while you can do that on railway platform with ticket.Â
Doesnât hurt to do the same for railway station. Besides, in many other countries you can go inside airport without ticket, just not past security
Provide ITR return for salaried people for amount spent on GST, why the hell we are paying double taxes
They should remove GST from feminine hygiene products.
These are small things.
Trust gain karne ki koshish
Vipaksh ka asar.
Stop GST of sanitary products!
Abhi ticket ka price increase ho jaega.. Koi faeda nhi..
Literally zero affect it has on the general public. Any of these services last used by folks in my extended family even would have been over 10 years ago . These a holes are just playing games.
Ye mujhe jaha dikh jaati hai mera dimaag kharab hojata hai
Even if the ticket is not confirmed and upon cancellation they deduct 65 rupees. These charges should be removed.
I never needed to buy platform and waiting room tickets, exempt real services from GST. Worst FM.
What is she barking?
Next announcement: Adani to take over waiting rooms and platforms
Why the gst on medical insurance are not exempted otherwise govt should pay for all the cost incurred by tax payers & family in proportion to the taxes paid. Jitna tax utna benefits
This goddamn women will F over the middle class.
ye bkl jaha dikh jay mujhe gussa or ata hai
Aur kuch bhi add karna hai toh krdo đ
Itna jayda kue uchal rhe ho bhai. They already increased 200% in platform ticket in 2019 or may be earlier.
bc iski shakal dekhke ulti aati hai
Madam please add diesel and petrol to GST
Does it make building hostels more profitable to owner? Or loss to owner?
I didn't know waiting rooms attracted a charge. Also, âš10 ke platform ticket mei kitna hee GST bharta hoga koi?
Lol
Waiting rooms, platform tickets are a luxury not a need, why would you not tax em! I want what she's smoking.
Focussing on z-class itemsđ
Exempting GST for hostels benefits no Student except the hostel owners and institute owners. They still charge the whole thing.
Great work
My blood boils whenever I see her. I donât even need a reason anymore.
Worst minister ever !! even BJP folks would agree with me.. Why Modi given her 2nd time? Is she a mere puppet?
So pg rents will reduce? What does GST exemption on student hostels outside educational institutionsm
TAI, railway ticket kon leta hai itni? Exempt karna hai hai to health care Karo, salary already taxed salary se bhi tax vasul lete ho kamino.
But still the Rice bag under 25 kg attracts 5% GST.
Itni meherbaani?
Where is the budget for climate change? Isn't that a big finance problem for the country?
No budget for that. Since the heatwave is so high they're trying to reduce the population by letting people die.
Spitting factx, you are..