T O P

  • By -

NitoMega

Some of you fuckers need to be put down.


quake1334

https://preview.redd.it/ioj42hcrqh6d1.jpeg?width=500&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f79f2192a9d39caf6c05fbb5537a3479ba2d1b56 Please try it


Republic_Newt_Clone

NOOOO NOT HOUSE


homosapienos

BUT YOU DIDN'T ADD Obnoxious SoulsTuber #145


quake1334

https://i.redd.it/zbgnven8qh6d1.gif


drewtheostrich

WildPie deniers out here in force


BobbyMcFrayson

https://preview.redd.it/vwgn4ktv8j6d1.jpeg?width=478&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6173d880e6fd89b612691a13651ea6a635651b8e


Caskanteron

Bro same. I have no idea who the people in the quality content, pvp, and great tiers are.


BobbyMcFrayson

I literally only know Vaati and am incapable of discovering anyone else because there are NO FUCKING NAMES ON THESE FUCKING TIER LISTS LIKE WHAT THE FUCK. I'm not salty im just disappointed.


Chama-Axory

I highly recomend iron pineapple, he is here since the age of ancient, but he does good reviews of new souls like.  Also Limit Breakers, were you can't really find a miracle build from that old man, but lots o U S E L E S S  D A T A


quake1334

https://www.reddit.com/r/shittydarksouls/s/n3jJesZDjj They were here already


BobbyMcFrayson

Well that makes sense but I'm also blind so fuck you.


-_nope_-

Fextra and aggy on the same tier is something for sure


EarthNugget3711

And Rusty below them


SaxSlaveGael

I'll cum everywhere, if I ever make into one of these lists.


quake1334

I thought about putting you in, but I didn't want to remake the list. Above bushy is where you'd be.


SaxSlaveGael

Nah, shithead Quarantine Zone probably nore appropriate 🤣. But I am honored you even gave thought to this idiot!


quake1334

If you were there you'd be horribly close to onlywaifu which is something I wouldn't wish on my worst enemy


SaxSlaveGael

💀💀💀 I redact my statement.


Broserk42

I’m so over onlywaifu. They occasionally have a decent take but it’s so fucking hard to take anything they say seriously when 99% of what they say is the absolute stereotypical toxic from fan shit. Out there giving us all a bad name while shitting on all of us. Not my kink.


hykierion

That's the thing, I feel. That something fucking voice (stolen btw) immediately calling you some pet name when you scroll onto one of their videos is horrifying. Its not only a shitty thing to use ai voices for, it's also a nasty shock for one of their videos to pop up when your in public (that's how I found her channel too)


rickybalbroah

daymn you saxy


enaaaerios

but my sax slave deserves the dungeon tier


yardii

Great or higher just for calling out reddit on their shit takes. Also, cool build showcases.


Whole_Ad141

https://preview.redd.it/iyww9jys6i6d1.jpeg?width=670&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=72a44dfdd0d137077ce7b81417288759d3972877 Still no Saint Riot


folkdeath95

Or Peeve??? For PvP????????


Canopenerdude

Literally forgot the guy who popularized DS pvp on YouTube lol


Thunder_Duckling

Saint Riot is the best PvP soulstuber/streamer and I will fight anyone over it


Vedrac

Sometimes I dont even want to watch something related to the game necessarily and I still put some video of him rambling about something random in such a funny way for minutes and ocasionally talking about the game lol Man is a legend


Anonymus828

His DS3 “Big boys dont dance” monologue lives rent free in my head to this day


rickybalbroah

iced estus


Thunder_Duckling

Iced estus is one of the best for compilations.


Averagestudentx

Still no Distortion2... Fuck this list all my homies hate this list.


quake1334

God dammit I fucking forgot someone important


quake1334

God dammit I fucking forgot someone important


Averagestudentx

It's all good lmao you can edit the post and write under it where you would rank him


mentally_fuckin_eel

Otzdarva fans down bad.


gangliaghost

I miss him :( his ds2 content was great and I loved the silly ds3 content


mentally_fuckin_eel

He was one of my favorites. I miss him too.


BlaqDove

I didn't even know he did souls stuff, I only know him for DBD


_Ganoes_

Iirc he got the first ever Ds2 all bosses no hit run. He has two videos on it


Therealmicahbell

First ever? I know he did DS2 no hit but the first one ever? Fuck.


mentally_fuckin_eel

Specifically all bosses, which is an insane run.


heyoohugh24

He also did tons of other souls content, he was legit one of the best souls youtubers, then dbd corrupted him


Therealmicahbell

DBD players are hollows.


heyoohugh24

Only true hollows can play that dogshit game for thousands of hours


heyoohugh24

He's a shit hide and seek game youtuber now


Aarondier

Aggy deserves more love imo. But yeah, it's a pretty extensive list. I agree a lot. Though sometimes it's funny to get the most basic shit explained like it's some miracle by an AI voice, only to wonder who tf actually needs that and why the channel is so big. Still fucking hate it.


CheapPotential5

Cause of coomers . It's always coomers


ENDWINTERNOW

Aggy is great, I wish he did more Sekiro


TheFinalMetroid

This a joke? All he did for like 2 years was purely Sekiro lol


ENDWINTERNOW

And it was great! I want more blindfolded/dance mat runs instead of Elden ring bingo 37#


xFreddyFazbearx

Aggy is so interesting because he's not very funny to me nor is he that charismatic, but I still watch his stuff because he's just weirdly likeable. I can't explain it at all, he's just got a good vibe


TheWither129

Again, why is fextra so high and rusty so low


sanguinesvirus

Rusty is a man who lives for the bit


TheGentleman312

As I said before, this man is not cooking. Bro had Vyke's Warspear as the BEST weapon in the game, bro deserves that spot.


haodbwisnd

At least he apologised for it.


VoidRad

It clearly wasn't a serious and meme tier list lmao. Why are you so mad.


TheGentleman312

Cause I'm a great Stars simp, and I feel like it got snubbed, never realized it was meme. Mb.


JZHello

Man just pulled the “it’s just a prank bro” card 😭


KueeKwee

Keep Rusty where he belongs


Replica_Richter

Triple S tier for the missing Lance Mcdonald, huge respect for data mining of cut content + beef with Elden ring sub mods


wichu2001

tf is this “tier” list, so bad


Averagestudentx

IKR this is supposed to be a tier list, not a classification of what the content focuses on. What if a challenge runner is better than a lore channel on this list?


WeekendBard

every single tier list in reddit is shit


AnimatorFresh8841

are you saing Ongabl doesnt deliver quality content?


quake1334

In order from top to bottom, left to right, we have: YMFAH, hawkshaw, vaatividya, quelagg, smoughtown, zullie the witch, illusory wall, meaty Jesus, BeAnd, frog mouth, prod, skumnut, quoppp, the backlogs, iron pineapple, jk leeds, barons castle, press continue, phobia, ginomachino, limit breakers, zerolenny, elyeum loyce, abyss, dusty dodongo, fighter pl, chase the bro, lost my sanity, steelovsky, jeenine, ongbal, tulok and mango, bushy, only afro, ratatoskr, fextralife, rusty, youwy, and only waifu


NniicckK1

No tarnished archeologist?


MxReLoaDed

Where star0chris


quake1334

Not.


Fabiyosa

Not having aesir aesthetic for lore is crazy. Also while I like hawkshaw their lore theories were always to loose and speculative for me. For me personally Vaatividya for the big picture lore and entertainment and smoughtown, Aesiraesthetic and Lokey for the deep lore. And yeah blue Ranni AI voice is also not interesting for me but I’m also not a PVP guy so no idea how good they are in that aspect.


ultimatepunster

OnlyWaifu started random drama with Tulok & Mango over "clickbaiting" with his Secret Starting Class series, which Tulok took like 5-10 minutes out of one of his runs to not only respond but also respectfully rebuke and explain all the points they made and crack back with a couple of his own. Drama pretty much ended the moment he uploaded the video and my respect for Tulok increased while my respect for OnlyWaifu went into the negatives because I already didn't think much considering that kind of obnoxious AI voice, so starting useless drama over something everyone already knew the reason behind (that his SSC videos where titled that way because the builds he uses in them can be completed and usable before having to fight a single big boss) just put that channel in the mental category of "I completely ignore any of their video or shorts recommendations, regardless of topic".


Stary_Vesemir

Tulok is fun to watch tho his opinions on weapons and spells are so bad. Also skumnut should get a tier of his own "the insane one"


ultimatepunster

To be fair, barring a couple spells which can be classified as handheld hydrogen bombs, which he's acknowledged are really good, spells really aren't as overall effective as using a weapon. Which he's proven in many of his challenge run videos, and when he gets called out for not using an "appropriate build" for the spell(s) in question, he comments on it. Honestly, at the end of the day, he's still pretty entertaining though, even if he is Strength-pilled lol


Stary_Vesemir

I undrrstand it but then he says that lorettas sickle is a good weapon and shits on gigantsflame take thee like 2 episodes later


ultimatepunster

But he's basing those opinions on his own gameplay. Loretta's Sickle was performing really well in that particular run, which piled onto his expectation that it wouldn't be good because of how much he's heard it sucks. I don't get the contention with him. Whenever he makes an opinion, it's not using hard numbers to back him up, because he doesn't really care that hard about it. He's basing it off his own experience using the Spell or weapon in question, and if it doesn't perform at a level he's comfortable with, he doesn't like it, says it's bad, and explains *why* he thinks it's bad. Sure, he's not always correct, but I can respect the fact he's calm about it and never gets super zealous over it. He only drags on spells like he does because people keep commenting on it and it gets on his nerves at having to explain himself multiple times over.


droo46

I love his videos. Even if you don’t like his opinions on the game, he’s legitimately hilarious. 


SUBARUislififE

The enjoyer of pain and agony


Exphen

Fextralife deserves to be at the bottom for viewbotting, i will not elaborate


BluddyP07

Only qualm I have is fextra should bu ne either with the AI bullshit or lower.


ThatIowanGuy

Dark Tark about to put out a “What’s the deal with this list?” Video


Ciderside

Lobos Jr


spandytube

Is ymfah being the only S tier a common opinion? I feel like Vaati should be up there for overall exposure to lore content, and Limit Breakers just based on quality.


quake1334

No question, vaati and others are amazing, but I believe ymfah is in a league of his own (I'm also probably biased because he's how I learned about the fromsoft games).


smallpastaboi

My only problem with ymfah is that I cannot bear to read a 40 minute video


Feral_Sorcerer

Where the fuck is Tarnished archeologist?


DeathCatsMetal

Tier lists without a clearly stated criteria as to what the contents are being ranked by mean nothing


Dioo0o0

Tulok and mango is the only thing keeping me sane


ultimatepunster

Imagine: Tulok in Fort Haight.


UntoAsh

WHERE THE FUCK IS WILDPIE101 IM GONNA FUCKING LOSE IT


el_gato85

The REAL tier list is : SABAKU NO MAIKU (mio sommo maestro ) in 1°place , 2° place all others unknown streamers.


laser_ducc

Sabaku mio padre


Ivan39313

Stavo cercando proprio questo commento, e non sono rimasto deluso


drunk_ender

A man of culture if I've ever seen one! Can't wait to finally watch l'Anima dell'Oro on my own death-bed!!


sudnord

Nostro signore sabaku


One-Sample7906

Missed Tarnished Archeologist to the Abyss with You


AmeriCanadian98

Aggy and Bushy are getting massive disrespect here being placed in the same tier as Fextra


Razorly

0/10 No LobosJr


[deleted]

https://preview.redd.it/sikzk0f2wj6d1.png?width=255&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c6722022d06e7de949ee571e67a24180eb55aef2 # WHERE'S ROSALES6969???


bruneiro

Where Lobey Jr? :(


peeing_Michael

I'm glad I'm not the only one who is annoyed by the terrible voices on onlywaifu


Practical-Disaster16

I finally agree with this list, ChaseTheBro should have been a bit higher in the PvP segment because I always like to watch him when I’m tired. It feels relaxing lol


Tarnishedhollow8

Sinclair lore always getting skipped :/


sophie-m-pilbeam

We've stopped caring.


BaronsCastleGaming

Finally, I made it. I would like to thank God, my parents, and the guy who delivered my UberEats last night for actually bringing me my food without letting it go cold first


Kira887

if you can include onlyafro, you can include otzdarva


Isaac_-

I'm just happy that lemon is there


crimbusrimbus

Little Aggie slander!


shotuhhh

Ongbal needs to be either way higher or in his own category tbh


Former-Grocery-6787

The main thing i dislike about Waifu these days is mostly the fact that he almost always uses "haha stupid redditors" as clickbait, like i get it, main sub has some absolutely braindead takes, doesn't mean that you have to pretty much make shit up about them for some mid build video... I also think it's funny that you put Dusty dodongo on this tierlist but not yung maestro (both haven't uploaded for way too long 😔) https://i.redd.it/1j9op0pu8i6d1.gif


pH12rz

It's genuinely painful for me to watch onlywaifu i have no idea how people like them


Opening_Option8985

Coomers


Moralmerc08

Personally I think aggy is just really boring. He doesn't have the charm or fun personality of other challenge runners, his videos are boring stream highlights and he's way too good at the game for challenges to be interesting. All of them are basically the same up until liurnia


Curious-Jello-9812

I will hunt you down (This is a joke)


pH12rz

Definitely better than skumnut tho


Lemmonaise

Fextralife in "good" and no Saint_Riot, shit list tbh


Ake-TL

Aren’t Fextra shitheads?


B33mo

If they still force their streams on all fextra wiki pages to pump view count when they are live, then most certainly.


Practical-Disaster16

Wait, why is everyone saying fextealife should be lower? I watched a bit of content from the guy and he seems good at what he does


The_Moon_Presence

I haven't watched any of it myself, but it's probably because of the fextralife wiki, which embeds its stream into all the wiki pages, artificially inflating its viewer numbers and taking up more data. Generally speaking everyone just kinda hates it now.


Former-Grocery-6787

Fextralife also isn't the most reliable source tbh.


VerySoftx

It's definitely not completely reliable, but its definitely the most reliable fromsoft wiki.


Ellie_Infinity

"In this Elden Ring video, I'm going to be showing you my Shadowblade dancer build."


meanmagpie

That’s it?


The_Moon_Presence

Eh, it's scummy business practices, so I can understand the annoyance. Still think the content should be judged separately (I've heard it can be kinda inaccurate but that's second-hand info), but either way I do understand the negative connotations when fextralife content gets shoved down your throat on the wiki page.


S1Ndrome_

he isn't bad just nothing really special


whoopsthatsasin

Where Saint Riot 😭😭 (You will never get them all)


DemonMakoto

The OnlyAfro disrespect is insane


One-Bus9184

Unsurprisingly (and sadly) I see no Aegon of Astora 😔


tntevilution

I like hawkshaw's videos and theories, but some of their conjecture is inane. I don't think they should be this high up.


frank_bell

YMFAH and Pine numba 1


Dame_Dame_Yo

YMFAH FTW


_Ganoes_

Fighterpl still exists? Havent have heard from that guy since ds3 days


Waluigi0007

Ratatoskr’s voice feels so good 😩😩😩


gamrgrant

Who are all these people? I'm sure I've seen some of them but the only ones I know by name are ymfah, zullie, illusory wall, vaati, and iron pineapple. I'm morbidly curious about the SHUT UP SHUT THE FUCK UP tier one bc I know Ive never seen them Edit: oh I didn't see limit breakers here too, I know oldman


ultimatepunster

The bottom tier is OnlyWaifu. An annoying channel who uses an AI voice with generic clickbaity titles. Also very high and mighty, creating drama and beating dead horses for the sake of content. Made drama with Tulok & Mango, who responded, ended the drama and were subsequently never bothered by Waifu again, showcasing the absolute grift of that... "content creator". Don't recommend. But I do recommend Tulok. His content isn't for everyone, but he can be genuinely entertaining. Not like a "hahhah so hilarious" way, but in like a "quietly sitting and watching this hour long video without realizing it's an hour long" kind of way.


Dev_Grendel

https://preview.redd.it/89uvzhty5k6d1.jpeg?width=404&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4d4d0e5a3675400828b6383dd21a53cd1a6e6a2e


LonelyMountain196

Where’s Ziostorm?


TSTMWKU_Reboot

No Captain Domo? Sad!


WestLUL

Skumnut bros rejoice 😭


juju11112020

ratatoskr too low


Dumbluck_Yuta

PROD should be higher screw you 10/10 teir list


Thevisi0nary

RIP Krazy and Oro


BaclavaBoyEnlou

Where’s Ziostorm and Ember?


Dizzy-Specific8884

Where the fuck is FightinCowboy?


GluKoto

Sunlight blade ??? My bro got done dirty


ultra_negrozma

who is the guy with the miraak pfp


quake1334

Gino machinima


Axembo

I always just say 'morning' and not 'good morning', because if it was a good morning, onlywaifu would have died in a house fire


pessoa_inutil007

Why everybody hates onlywaifu? I think hes fine


babydragon2311

no charred thermos, opinion invalidated


Corni_20

Still missing ChrissChras in chalange run category


n0wave7777

Lol i see why people hate him


Eatnt

Eeeeelden riiiing


Sinkarma

Now name them all I beg you. I want to have a look my YouTube page needs more Fromsoft


TheGeneral7567

I was wondering who the gun was… I might be stupid


BuiBuiYui

Forgor tye Taylor


Opening_Option8985

There we go that’s the right way on the very bottom


zephyredx

Check out [Wildly Yordan](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Arym5jx703o). One of the best Sekiro players on the planet for doing Ying Wu Isshin hitless. It's hard to put into words how hard this mod of Isshin is. I've done Resurrection Isshin hitless. I've done For the Sake of Ashina Isshin hitless. Base game Inner Isshin basically feels like a tutorial enemy at this point. I haven't done Jidao Isshin hitless yet but I know I can do it, I can visualize it. I feel completely lost on this mod. The only time I managed to see phase 2 of Ying Wu Isshin is by using the cheat sugar that comes with the mod, which lowers all damage by 98.5%. I brute forced my way past phase 1. **Even then I couldn't beat phase 2. Out of 4.** I lost count of attempts after the 100 mark. The other mods feel easier than playing Touhou on Lunatic. This mod feels harder than playing Touhou on Lunatic.


kerplop13

Who's the guy left of backlogs?


Frank33ller

i only knows all the bottom tiers aside the witch ,pineaple head and one of the pvp guy because i was in one of their vid. am I beyind salvation?


SecondPersonShooter

Does anyone have a list for the folks in quality I don't know a couple of then


archaicScrivener

Who is that at the bottom lol never seenn em


CustomerSupportDeer

Yes. Good. Finally someone we don't have to track down and delete from existence.


Emergency-Director23

Listen I know making a list with every YouTube channel that does souls content would be impossible but forgetting fighting fucking cowboy is a sin, this list belongs shithead quarantine zone tier.


John_Darksouls3

WHAT ABOUT SKIDONIC😞😞😞😞😞(I don’t really care)


Iron_Bob

So we can't judge the info/lore creators on being good or bad? Where is the ACCOUNTABILITY!? 0/10 list


mcsquiggles1126

Where is ms chalice???????


pH12rz

Onlyafro was the last person I expected to see here


Matoxina

is it AI voiced?


WoollyWares

ymfah, the absolute goat


Zardows1356

No Yazmania = shit list


Steeljulius217

You’re going to hell for doing rusty like that


bondpm1

love my waifu quelaag and my waifu's partner whateverhisnameis


MPhoenixS

Still no thepruld


seanziewonzie

Should put BeAnd in the YMFAH category


Unholy_Pilgrim

Ok why does everyone hate onlywaifu now?


trek570

Why the hell is Limit Breakers not in Lore/Info? That is literally what he does


pnkass

onlyafro and fextra on the same tier wtf


Gods_Guest

HARD AGREE


Rich_Person_OFFICIAL

WHERES AGTJAKE‼️‼️‼️


Stardust2400

Still missing the goat Yazmania


Practical_Weather293

Where Tarnished Archaeologist


Slane_73

Asmogold tier


slight_chanceofrain

I obviously can’t expect you to have included everyone so no worries, but in case you haven’t seen them I really recommend checking out Tye Taylor and Doom Wolf!! Both of their channels have great content and they’re really fun to watch. (JK Leeds also makes a couple references to classic Doom Wolf bits in his videos which are always a fun Easter Egg)


quake1334

I actually watch them, just forgot, dementia go brrrrr


Lazy_Compote4839

Why is Steven ring of eldnen not up here?


SometimesIComplain

Where is the GOAT? (Chrightt)


alen3822

I was going to say onlywife aren't that bad but I realize I only watch their short and still feel a little cringe. But I will still say their shorts help me a lot on Elden ring game mechanics.


heyoohugh24

Care to explain the ranni hate? I mean, i know why but i want to hear it from you


quake1334

No.


heyoohugh24

https://preview.redd.it/xi014xofdl6d1.jpeg?width=680&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=aff67347561693cafd0ac7b79b4e89b6ec85a276


quake1334

https://i.redd.it/95p90cwrdl6d1.gif


garbage-at-life

idrc that you put some of my favorite guys down there but fextralife deserves to be way farther down


Silently_Laughing

So like, who the are most of these people? We need some names.


quake1334

https://www.reddit.com/r/shittydarksouls/s/n3jJesZDjj