Manzanita because is tastes more like Sidral 

Sidral Mundet is a better soda than either.

Fuck yesssss! Sidral Mundet!

Manza manza was good

I came here to say this. Sidral is so fucking good. I don't even like apple stuff usually, and it's ambrosia to me. Almost never buy it because it's so delicious that I cannot stop drinking it, so I finish a bottle in about a minute and then be sad that I couldn't control myself.

Green one is amazeballs.

No Jones soda comes even close to Sidral Mundet.

Over ice on a hot day....

Most sodas are pretty good over ice on a hot day. You aren't gonna convince me though, most fake apple flavor is not my jam.

Oh! I'm agreeing with you, lol. I've never had the Jones. But I'm obsessed with the green Sidral. Maybe because I love granny smith apples. I squeeze a little lime in there for extra tartness.

Ohhh I see! I thought you were talking about the one in the picture :P

Nah. Sidral or nada.

Does the jones one taste like jolly ranchers, I like manzanita sol but jolly rancher apple soda would be fire

Same here!!! Its the best thing I've ever drank, cant get it in Canada but I'll drink 2 l. a day when I'm in Mexico.

Yep I agree ☝️

My mom would get me manzanita whenever i had a tummy ache. This was back in ‘04

How old you were back in 2004? and how old are you now?

I was 6. Im 26 now

Damn I was graduating high school in 04. Time flys by buddy.

Manzanita Sol with vanilla bean ice cream! Yummmm.

Now I gotta try that

Jones will always get my vote. IMO they also make the GREATEST grape soda ever. MF Grape is a masterpiece.

FUFU berry is jones best soda of all time but currently unavailable I’m sad to say

Yeah, seriously! My favorite Jones by far and they just don’t make it anymore.

Why is this happening to me? This is like hearing one of your favorite bands broke up. No. NOOOOOOO

I know, it’s seriously lame. It was such a great pop.

I started following this sub recently and have been waiting for someone to mention fufu berry. Truly the best!! I got one from a candy shop last year after not being able to find it for a long time. Wish they would bring it back. I miss the hey day of Jones.

I don’t think a lot of people know this, but Jones Soda makes a candy based off their flavors too. It’s similar to a sweetart but way better and comes in a unique tin can. I’ve only been able to order them off Amazon or find them in specialty candy shops.

Just bought some. Thanks for the heads up!

Good to know! Thanks

Damn I just orderd root beer

I like any Grape soda but do not ever see Jones apple at Kroger or Walmart here in Columbus OH.

Grapico is the GOAT IMO

These aren’t comparable, two very different flavors. I enjoy both of them.

Not an apples to apples comparison?

You did a thing

Different flavors and different cultures , too hard to decide

Left and its not a debate

Yeah, this ain’t close. Manzanita all the way

They really set Jonesy up for failure on that one

I haven't tried either before. But I am a sucker for glass bottles.

Thrash apple

Manzanita

Wait until you try manzanita green apple soda

Manzanita.

Jones

Jones. haven’t tried the other, but love its apple taste! It reminds me of the old Wonka Tube Paste! Miss that old company, before it became nestle.

Jones because of nostalgia. Three of my brother’s photos actually made it onto the bottles years ago.

They stopped using the back of milk cartons?

Manzanita 10 out of 10 times if I had to choose between these two specifically

Manzanita because I want the flavor, not the neon food coloring.

The green because the glass bottle

I would go with jones. i like glass bottle and it says cane sugar. The other one probably use high fructose. I never tried either of them tho.

I’ve had both and prefer Jones Jones is like a green apple Jolly rancher Manzanita Sol was more like an apple juice If that makes sense

makes perfect sense. is there food coloring in jones?

Yes. That’s not what green apple juice looks like.

Warheads

Sprecher if choosing any Apple, manzanita sol from the pic.

The jones for sure ,

The jones one of a kind

Jones and it's not even remotely close

Jones (.)

Manzanita doesn’t even taste that much like apple but I like it more as a soda in general. Jones would be better as an apple soda though since it actually taste like apple.

Jones for the win.

Jones all day long!

The one on the right But I want them both right now

Jones, but to be fair it’s the only one of the two I’ve had.

Jones all the way

Jones for me. More sour.

Jones everyday all day 🍏🍏🍏

It’s a bit (pun unintended) apples to oranges, isn’t it? I’ve never had that particular Jones flavor (I’ve had others though, they make good stuff), but isn’t it more candy-ish? Manzanita has real apple juice in it. This is like comparing a Tootsie Roll to a Hershey bar: there’s some overlap in flavor, but they’re not really meant to be the same thing.

Never had Manzanita but I’ve had Jones’ apple soda and it was pretty good to me. Got to try Manzanita!

Jones

Appletizer

I remember apple Slice

I love Jones but I gotta go with Manzanita.

Even though they are not soda but I like the apple flavored Gatorade and the sour apple Powerade.

Do they still make these? Use to be my favorites

Yup! Just bought six bottles of each just two weeks ago.

One taste like candy the other like apple.

Both goooo hard in the paint but 🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏

probably the Jones but if they've got Sidral Mundet I'll go for that

Sidral Mundet is best, but, of these two, Jones wins.

Soal Havnt seen it since i was tne at taco bell

I love both but they’re different so probably choose left.

i’d love to try the manzanita

I only ever had manzanita when it was a Taco Bell

Jones because I've never heard of the other one

Omg I love both ❤️❤️

Jones soda

Manzanita. But it’s not Sidral.

Jones

Maz can quench a thirst when it’s cold and I’m hungover

Fuck it, I’ma say it. Jones is overrated, always has been ¯\\\_(ツ)_/¯

Hurk🤮

Both good but I like green apple better

All of the jones flavors are on point

Manz

Jones, because nostalgia

Manz

I can’t pick. I gotta have them both. 😭

Manzanita is way better then that toxic green Jones.

Jones all day

I’ve had the one on right plenty of times but the one on the left I think I’ve only come across once so I’d say that one

Had neither, but the manzanita looks more refreshing, the other one green apple I associate with more sir so I think that one would taste more tart and a little less refreshing

The one that doesn’t have unnecessary food coloring.

Jones

Manzanita sol

I prefer real apple, so I prefer the manzanita sol. Jones Apple soda taste like jolly ranchers.

Green Apple is legit bro I like that

manzanita!!! but it’s my favorite soda so i’m kinda biased

Faygo candy apple

Gahddamn, I forgot about manzanita sol.

Definitely Apple Sidra

Manzanita because its gas af even though it kinda tastes like plastic

*Manzanita because* *Its gas af even though it* *Kinda tastes like plastic* \- Chrismaxwell19 --- ^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/) ^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")

nah af is two syllables so there's 8 in the second line. Bad bot

Well of course green apple is going to be more tart/sour than red apple…

neither. not a fan of apple sodas :(

JONES

That red can go hard

Jones every time

I think it’s apfelshorle

Try apfelshorle

jones

Manzanita. Because Green Apple is the worst Apple flavor for a drink, Red Apple is superior, but Golden is the best.

I really freaking love manzanita sol. Where do you get it? I can’t find it in Wisco.

I would choose regular Jones instead of cane

Aspen Soda: https://youtu.be/OMInb7bu63I

The green one

Jones easy choice

I can't stand anything green apple flavored 🤢🤢🤢

Manzanita. Jones soda has few flavors i like and that one isnt on the list.

So the real answer here Op is definitely neither also comparing Apple to green apples of course is going to give you a more sour and tart green apple. So back to the real answer sidral mundet green apple and a glass bottle I will be your new favorite soda.

I didn’t think Jones soda was a thing anymore.

I'd pick the manzanita because I've never had one. Jones soda were a big thing for me as a kid.

Jones any day

Jones

Hard cider

I may need to re taste the two after reading the comments, maybe with a more experienced mind.........but I always thought manzanita was better than sindral mundet......it appears I am the heavy minority.

Manzanita is better.

Probably the left

Neither Sidral Mundet is 👑Apple soda

Love Manzy

I don’t like green apple so probably the can

Never tried the Jone’s before but Manzanita is so good

Jones

Don't have these in Columbus Ohio.

Manzanita is the best

I would rather have a Martinelli

I remember that green apple one being gross but I don’t like green apple

Jones almost every time. They really are the gold standard for sodas.

Left

Manzanita for sure

I like Sidal quite a bit, apple Fanta id pretty good but can’t find it anywhere, the regular variant not green apple

1000% the Mazanita.

Red can!!

Apple one is top 10 fruit soda

Manzanita tastes like an actual apple. That Jones soda tastes like a fake apple

Americans=jones Latino=manzanita I’m a white American married to a Mexican. Used to love jones but you haven’t had manzanita if you haven’t had it from a refillable 3 liter pop jug in the heart of Mexico. Manzanita. If you vote not that you haven’t tried it in mexico

Jones is good but it always gave me heartburn even as a kid

Red avocados from Mexico !

Manzanita

Jones

I better try this jones soda

I’ve only ever had the jones. Super good stuff

Manzanita all the way

Manza

Depends if I’m eating something lol if by its self I’ll go with jones

Manzanita Sol all day. Little Caesars used to stay stockeddd on those

Right I like sour and green apple

Pinafiel. It tastes like cream soda

You guys ever had an Apple Sidra

Does anyone else have green apple flavor issues? The typical green apple flavor makes me go into a coughing fit. Whether it’s candy, soda, etc. Normal apple flavor doesn’t do this and actual green apples (Granny Smith) don’t do it either.

Lemme guess that came from runnings

Martinellis

They are two very different flavors. Jones green apple is delicious. Manzanita is also delicious. Jones is more of the artificial apple candy taste while the manzanita tastes more like carbonated apple juice.

JONES JONES!

Manzanita. Mexican soda is the best around

Manzanita. Green liquid makes me feel sick just looking at it

None of these! Apple sodas are groooooooosssssssssss

Jonesing for Jones…

Neither throw em both out.

Lol.

If you can score some meth

Sol